• THE OPTIMAL PATH FORWARD IN GERMANY

    OPTIMISING YOUR business strategy based on THE INCENTIVES PROVIDED BY THE GERMAN COMBINED HEAT AND POWER ACT

Market background in Germany

The coal exit law adopted in 2020 sets out a roadmap for shutting down Germany’s remaining coal power capacity by 2038. The reduction in electricity generation from coal-fired power plants is to be offset through investments in renewable energy sources, among other measures.

The recently amended Kraft-Wärme-Kopplungsgesetz (KWKG), also known as the CHP Act, is to be continued until 2026. It encourages the replacement of coal-fired power plants with CHP facilities, offering a one-time coal-replacement bonus for new plants and incentivises innovative renewable heat production with an increased CHP bonus.

THE OPTIMAL PATH FORWARD IN GERMANY

Determining the optimal path forward

THE OPTIMAL PATH FORWARD IN GERMANY

The bonuses offered by the updates to the CHP Act will be beneficial to CHP plant owners and CHP providers in Germany. However, exactly how best to take advantage of the act remains unclear. This lack of clarity is what led Wärtsilä to conduct a modelling exercise to determine the optimal capacity mix depending on the CHP plant technology used and the different share of renewable heat production. The modelling was conducted using PLEXOS energy simulation software.

In addition to the CHP plant, the model also built a certain capacity of heat pump and heat storage; the exact capacity varies between scenarios depending on the CHP plant technology and the share of renewable heat in the system. In general, the modelling produced the following results:

  1. There is a direct correlation between CHP plant capacity and heat pump capacity.
  2. The footprint of the RES-based heat source is important in determining the optimal level of investment.
  3. Flexible engines offer the lowest heat-generation prices.

Wärtsilä Energy: Modelling rapid coal phase-out in Europe

We want to show how energy security can be maintained without coal by 2030 while promoting energy independence and affordability

Investing in renewable heat makes financial sense for German CHP providers

Based on the modelling results, investing in renewable heat makes sound financial sense for German CHP providers.

Including renewable heat generation will significantly improve the business case of a new CHP plant – indeed, the more renewable heat used, the better the business case becomes. Engine CHP plants lead to the most cost-efficient outcome.

Their combination of high single-cycle efficiency and flexibility results in heat generation prices that are 10–15% lower than for turbine-based alternatives.

Benefits:

  • While all CHP plant options (engine, CCGT, OCGT) result in lower heat-generation prices, engines lead to the most cost-efficient outcome, with heat generation prices that are 10–15% lower than for turbine-based alternatives.
  • Switching away from coal, and increasing the share of RES-based heat, reduces emissions.
  • In the future, when using engine CHP plants, emissions can be reduced even further with the possibility to use synthetic or biofuels.
  • Engines can be quickly ramped up or stopped, offering more flexible operation. This enables the plant to closely follow the price signals from the electricity market, resulting in higher average prices for electricity sold.
The study recommends adding ICE

Wärtsilä - your partner in coal phase-out

Germany is phasing out coal, and the recently amended CHP Act provides financial incentives for providers to invest in innovative renewable heat. Based on the results of PLEXOS modelling conducted by Wärtsilä, there is a compelling business case for CHP providers to include RES-based heat.

This business case is further enhanced if a coal-fired plant is replaced with a non-coal-fired CHP. The exact percentage of RES-based heat to include in the generation mix needs to be determined on a case-by-case basis according to the unique parameters for a given provider. Wärtsilä can model each case individually to determine the optimal way for customers to leverage the opportunities presented by the CHP Act.

Wärtsilä is committed to providing customers with future-proof solutions to support the transition towards a 100% renewable energy future and help decarbonise the society.

Video: Energy Transition Talks with Sushil Purohit and swb Bremen

We decided to have a solution that is a good balance between cost efficiency, reliability, availability and climate protection

Related materials

Contact us

Please fill in the form, we aim to respond within 1-2 business days depending on the enquiry. For an existing installation, provide all necessary details to identify the installation and the equipment. Fields indicated with an asterisk (*) are required.

Find your local Wärtsilä office here